Archive

Posts Tagged ‘mafia wars’

Mafia Wars – I quit.

January 4th, 2010

It wasn’t that difficult.  I just stopped clicking on the icon in my quick launch bar.

The reason behind my quitting is simple.  The game doesn’t end, it doesn’t progress, it doesn’t have a compelling storyline.  For awhile it was fun to see how many levels I could progress through – to try and catch my friends.  But once I got into the 125-130+ range, the fun just stopped.  So now the game sits at my current level:

I know the revelation that nothing happens in the game  & that it doesn’t progress are not earth shattering.  In fact I knew that going into it.  For that matter I’m impressed that millions of other people have played & will play [progress] much farther than I will.

The game makes money & people want to play it.  Good for them.  I quit.

Mafia Wars

August 31st, 2009

I can’t stop playing…

Well, that’s not entirely true…

At level 32 the fun for me has started to ebb.  It’s not that the gameplay has changed – it hasn’t.  It’s not that it’s even any less addictive.  What has changed is how obvious the lack of balanced gameplay is…

There’s ONE HUGE AREA that I think needs to be reexamined from the ground up.

MAFIA SIZE

Now I get this from a marketing position.  By constantly offering RARE items & other power-ups to Mafia’s that ALWAYS seem to be 1-3 members above where I am – the game is trying to encourage me to get my other friends who are not playing to get in on it.  I get it – it’s trying to  spread like a VIRUS.   Now that mechanic is established here’s why it SUCKS…

I don’t have very many friends.  I have even fewer friends who play Mafia Wars.  So my little MAFIA of 19 has hard time competing with any mafia with even 2-3 more people in it.  So while I may be evenly matched from a LEVEL perspective with MANY other players – that number is ultimately TRUMPED by the size of the Mafia.

Again – I get this too.  There’s an ATTACK/DEFENSE bonus that’s built into MAFIA SIZE.  But – there’s is NO APPARENT level restrictions or mafia size restrictions when attacking people.  What this ultimately leads to is that with VERY FEW EXCEPTIONS I will always – ALWAYS – attack someone lower than me.  Both in LEVEL & MAFIA SIZE.  I’ve also noticed this happens to me when I’m attacked.  It’s almost ALWAYS someone from higher level & bigger Mafia.

Ultimately this mechanic is a COLOSSAL FAILURE from a game balance perspective.  The ONLY reason for this mechanic’s existence is to grow the amount of people playing the game.  Otherwise I cannot imagine a designer would not think – WAIT – this. does. not. work.

That’s all.  Mafia size being tied to ATTACK/DEFENSE stats creates unbalance problems that make the game less & less fun the higher I get with a SMALL mafia.